Tuesday, August 6, 2019

Changing the Narrative, Seizing the Initiative


Changing the Narrative
For the past almost 100 years those behind the idea of Pakistan have been seizing the narrative and forcing us to be reactive. They have always provoked conflict and then pretended to be victim. Through this strategy they have got away with murder and genocide, exterminating their own people and hardly facing any consequences. We have always been on the defensive. Two illuminating examples are: i) the efforts that it took India to explain to the world that genocide was happening in erstwhile East Pakistan and ii) that India is a victim of cross-border terrorism, which was fomenting the separatist movement in Kashmir.

Since before it's creation, proponents of the Pakistan ideology have bred and cultivated hatred against India. Their raison-de-etre is contra-India. While the list of what they have been doing is endless here is an attempt to enumerate a few instances:
- Formation of Muslim League and demand for Pakistan;
- Collaboration with the British during the World War II;
- Forcing the decision on the formation of Pakistan by perpetrating the Great Calcutta killings;
- Massacre of innocents during the partition;
- Making India the sole target & focus of its foreign policy and diplomacy, always attempting to humiliate India in international forums; while parroting the demand for implementation of UNSC resolutions, conveniently ignoring to implement their own obligations;
- the calculated nexus with China, which is clearly anti-India;
- joined international alliances during the Cold War such as SEATO and CENTO to obtain military advantage against India;
- genocide in Bangladesh & no trials of the war criminals;
- systematic elimination of religious and ethnic minorities- Hindus, Christians, Shias, Ahmediyas, Pashtuns, Mohajirs, amongst others - they have either been forced to convert or fled the country and those who remain there are in perpetual fear as second class citizens;
- propping up a medieval ideology in terms of the Taliban and thereby;
- blatantly undermined the Western/US military in Afghanistan resulting in the failure of their efforts to bring peace to Afghanistan;
- mercilessly destroyed the culture and identity of its constituent provinces- Sindh, Balochistan and NWFP;
- in the name of fighting terrorism, perpetrated genocide on the Pashtuns in FATA; bombed and strafed civilians using bombers, helicopter gunships and fighter aircraft;
- develop a military state, constantly at war with India;
- started (and lost) 4 wars with India- 1948, 1965, 1971 & 1999, bringing misery to mostly to their own people;
- have ceaselessly tried to change the balance of power in the region by inducting advanced weapon systems such as F-16, developed a clandestine nuclear and missile programme with the help of proliferators;
- support terrorism in Punjab;
- blatantly support Kashmiri separatists and perpetrate terrorism in India resulting in killing of more than 40,000 people in Kashmir itself;
- being behind the violence against the Kashmiri Pandits resulting in their flight from the valley;
- openly support hijacking of civilian aircraft and give sanctuary to hijackers
(the Kandahar case among others);
- give shelter to terrorists and criminals, be it Masood Azhar or Dawood or Osama Bin Laden;
- while claiming to be the saviour of Kashmir, deviously ceded part of the Pakistan occupied territory of Kashmir to China;
- separated Gilgit Baltistan from so called Azad Kashmir and almost made it into what is euphemistically called as 'Northern Areas', the country's fifth province;
- changing the demography in Occupied Kashmir. So much so that the President of the so called Azad Kashmir is a non-Kashmiri;
- systematically destroying Kashmiri culture in occupied Kashmir;
*****************
Today, August 5, 2019, with the abrogation of Articles 370 and 35A, India has changed the narrative and seized the momentum. It is a momentous day for India. It will take time to see and realize the implications of today's decision. The struggle is generational, what has been done will benefit future generations of Indians. It has an important collateral of taking out the wind of Pakistan's sails. Pakistan has always tried to change the status quo with respect to its neighbours be it India (through aggression and cross-border terrorism) or Afghanistan (it's strategic depth policy). In recent times, they had once again demanded of world powers (notably US) to bring pressure on India to negotiate on Kashmir in return for helping in Afghanistan. Now that India has changed the status quo by actions entirely internal and domestic, it is crying wolf. This move by India has deprived Pakistan of their blackmailing strategy vis-a-vis Afghanistan. They will now scramble to find another narrative to play victim hood. Another false narrative that has been peddled for too long and not been countered is the so called "right to self determination" of the people of Kashmir. It is totally absurd, baseless and illegal as is the right of say the people of Kosi Kalan or Kolkata to self determination. The aspirations of the people of India for self determination have been met through the "India Independence Act 1947". Period. No other peoples of India have that right. The Indian union is now permanent and indestructible. For eternity.

A new era has dawned today for India and the people of Kashmir. The idea of India has been strengthened. We will be the story tellers now on and we will tell our story.

39 comments:

  1. Good compilation of all the nefarious activities of Pakistan that forced us to be reactive. The master stroke by Modi Administration - as you very insightfully said -has deprived Pakistan of blackmailing India and USA vis a vis Afghanistan. That indeed was a brilliant act by our govt!!
    Very lucidly written Ambassador Chakraborty!!!
    Dr.Ajey Jain

    ReplyDelete
  2. This should be the first of many initiatives which we should seize. Pakistan has long been blackmailing international community with all its lies and deception. We already called its bluff after Pulwama. Scrapping Art. 370 was so logical but had proved so difficult. Kudos to our leadership.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bandhu superb insight. Thanks for sharing your thoughts

    ReplyDelete
  4. Excellent write sir, Namaskar. Jai hind

    ReplyDelete
  5. very thoughtful and great compilation of events and tactics used by pakistan. Thank you CG being direct and on point.

    ReplyDelete
  6. above comment. from nikhil @ VT

    ReplyDelete
  7. This blog is an inspiration to the inspired towards the vision of change.
    Modern day diplomats vision to debate, discuss and rectify the past so that with the understanding bridges can be built.
    This is a blog representing the modern vision of change.
    Eshita Chakrabarti
    Anchor/producer

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dear Sir. Excellent narrative . Very brief and informative. Actually you have given us complete picture . Thank you so much. Warm regards rajeev ketkar

    ReplyDelete

  9. Nice! I wonder why India does not raise the issue of UNSC resolution on Kashmir demanding Pakistan to vacate Kashmir as per their agreement to do so?

    ReplyDelete

  10. Nice! I wonder why India does not raise the issue of UNSC resolution on Kashmir demanding Pakistan to vacate Kashmir as per their agreement to do so?
    - Bal Ram Singh

    ReplyDelete
  11. As always very articulate your views sir. I would also like to add that the gateway to terrorisim has been shut for good with this action. Even China has been rattled with Ladak being named a UT. Now we should keep the momentum and show the world India is not a pushover. Jai hind!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great insight on the nefarious designs of Pakistan all these years. Hoping to see a more peaceful and terrorism free India in the coming years.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great listing Sir! A bright future awaits India.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Immaculately penned articulated insight and informative narrative. Your blog exposes the lies and deceptions Pakistan had been bragging on for years to blackmail the international community and also earn their sympathy on name of Kashmir.
    Excellent write up Sandeep.
    Hope the momentum continues for a peaceful and safe India.
    Jai Hind !!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Above comments by:
      ☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️
      Pallav Shah,
      Boston .

      Delete
  15. Great piece. Thank you. We should share first with our Doubting Desis
    And then with those who are genuinely interested in knowing the real history.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Excellent compilation and just enough description of each event as necessary.
    I wish this is published in news media worldwide, just to give a glimpse of the facts which were misrepresented all along these years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Above comments are by srini srikoti, Lansdale,PA.

      Delete
  17. Thank you for the explanation. Hope everything will be better for everyone from now on.

    ReplyDelete
  18. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Excellent narration. Article 370 was always a thorn in the 'Indian' flesh. We took it and tolerated it so long thinking that everything will be alright. All the Kashmiri Pandits were driven out of the valley, treated the Indian bureaucrats and military personnel with utmost hatred , enjoying all the privileges still they are not happy, not realizing life as a Pakistani is worse than hell. They should understand there is a limit to everything.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Excellency, fabulous narration. Loved it and sharing too!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Excellent, narrated to the best possible perfection....besides Pakistan, Indian politics played a big roll!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Excellent narrative, CG Chakraborty! The crisp yet complete historical landscape you drew helps the reader view this permanent ‘Change of Narrative’ in the proper perspective. Enjoyed the ‘Game Theory’ aspect of the blog as well - as well as the recognition that the struggle is Generational. No quick fixes but a huge step towards a much-needed paradigm shift in the Indo-Pak-World relationship.
    ~ Himadri Chatterjee, NYC

    ReplyDelete
  23. At the end, I hope that the two governments can agree to root out terrorism in Kashmir. I don’t know when that end will come. As you stated Sandip, the effects of this bold and just action by the Indian government will arrive, but not yet. Humanity is the greatest religion of all and binds us all together. Let Justice be done, let humanity thrive, let love prosper. Jai Hind...

    ReplyDelete
  24. This is a lucid blog, dear Ambassador Chakravorty. Your piece reaffirms that there are two lessons that ALL Indians need to learn, once and for all: 1. We need to solve our (National) problems ourselves, and 2. If we operate from Values and Principles that are rooted in what's good for all (the greater good of humanity, globally) we should not flinch if we have to defend these values by force. For instance, while 'Peace' and 'Truth' are Values that we cherish and uphold, we should not hesitate to go to subdue an adversary that is trying to foment aggression and violence, through lies and falsehood.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Detailed analysis of an issue that has been a harbinger of so much discontent and discord. It is dangerous to pass a judgement. But when humanity is at stake, justice becomes imperative. We have hurled defiances everytime our integrity has been questioned. This one was long due. Loved the flow of the article. Fluent writing. A certain simplicity in its tone that can only reflect truth and honesty.

    ReplyDelete
  26. You should write more often, Ambassador! This is well articulated. Until I read this, I actually didn´t think of the abrogation of Articles 370 and 35A as a way for India to seize the narrative with Pakistan, but after reading your post, I believe we need to be following more such proactive rather than reactive policies vis-a-vis Pakistan. In fact, the raison-de-etre of the Pakistan army and security establishment is to be anti-India, and that is precisely what has allowed them to control that country since their formation. If Kashmir seizes to be an issue, they will have no purpose.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Bravo !!! Excellent narrative Sandeep Da...truly hope such articles are published among wider communities.
    Time for such proactive policies by Indian Govt. to set the stage straight.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Sandeeji, excellent narration, will share it

    ReplyDelete
  29. Being obsessed is a vital energy. .... unfortunately, Pakistan has been obsessed negatively.

    From a long-term perspective, we need to push them towards lots to work on positive side.

    Will be good for them & region.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Superb blog, I can visualize India’s freedom & division, how anti India forces tried to defame our unity, sovereignty, peace and calm since independence.

    ReplyDelete
  31. So eloquently written - like everything Mr. Chakravorty touches!

    ReplyDelete
  32. Honorable Sandeep ji, excellent narrative of the entire hundred (100) years of regions history, please also add the recnet activity of infirtaltion from Myanmar side and taking advantage of Rhonigya refugees.
    The ideology and philosophy is rooted even today with say, "लडके लिया पाकिस्तान, हस के लेंगे हिंदुस्थान". India took the right steps and history will prove it's right step towards entire regions development. Jai Hind!!

    ReplyDelete
  33. Great article! I shared it with people who have difficulty in understanding the issue and they understood it. Thanks for simplifying. Looking forward to other articles. - Abhishek

    ReplyDelete
  34. A very insightful narrative. The abrogation of article 370 has put the onus on Pakistan to terminate all its nefarious activities vis a vis J&K, since it has become a domestic issue in India. Even Islamic countries fail to support Pak's stand on J&K. Ambassador Chakravorty has meticulously listed chronologically Pak's frequent infringement of India's sovereignty. Kudos to your narrative.

    ReplyDelete

Life After Life

  It was through the Indian Express headlines today that I learnt about the passing away of Dr. Bibek Debroy: " Four days before he pas...